Gardy and I Can be like Two Peas in a Pod
Gardy has done something that really irked me most of the season. His #2 hitters were out of place. He was batting #7-9 hitters there. He was putting guys in the 2 hole who just got out too much. This season, the Twins #2 hitters have had an OBP of .310. For comparison, Boston has had a .361 OBP from their second batter. This fact has had myself been begging for the Twins to quit putting poor OBP guys in the #2 hole. Most notably, Bartlett should have never batted second. When batting there he had a .301 OBP. Really quite poor. Seven of ten times at the plate Jason got out. That is an out that takes away at bats from the rest of the hitters that follow him. Mauer and Morneau would also have less runners on base every time they came to the plate.
Other notables inserted there include Castro and Rivas who have had sub .200 OBP there. Simply awful! Otherwise, a complete waste in the lineup. It is one thing to have a waste batting ninth, but a whole other mess when it is the player who gets the 2nd most plate appearances on the team.
Nick Punto is the only player that has helped bring up our team OBP up. He has had a .380 OBP when batting in the two hole, which is pretty good. That is good if he could keep it up, but with an OBP of .345 on the season and .340 last year he is bound to come back to his average numbers. Another point is that Punto doesn't play every day (like he should) and only plays against matchups that are more favorable than if he had to play every day. His numbers are likely to drop off a bit.
My wish of a worty #2 hitter was granted a few games ago. The player I had been begging for Gardy to move to 2nd in the lineup was put there. JOE MAUER! Joe Mauer is the perfect guy for the #2 spot. Sure he isn't as fast as a guy like Bartlett or Punto but he gets on base about 40% of the time! For every 10 plate appearance he commits 6 outs while our #2 hitters this season commited 7 outs. That provides more at bats for the hitters behind him as well as more baserunners.
Now if Mauer is at #2 you might wonder what happens to the #3 spot in the lineup. Well, in the game Mauer batted second, Ford was inserted at #3. This is a downgrade in terms of OBP and slugging, but I suspect that Ford's numbers will get a boost batting in front of Morneau. Therefore, the power remains there. Not only that, but our lineup becomes more effective in terms of left and right handed matchups. With a R-L-R-L lineup at 1-4, opposing teams cannot throw a left handed specialist to get out both Mauer and Morneau because Ford protects them. This provides better matchups for each of player and would improve all of their numbers across the board.
After the game he batted second, Mauer has skipped a few starts to rest. My dream lineup was effectively destroyed. Now I hope that when Mauer returns, so will the lineup with him at the #2 spot. I would not be surprised if Punto was inserted at #2 and Mauer at #3, but I would be let down a bit. Not as let down as if Castro was put there, but I would be let down. Hopefully Gardy will continue the Mauer @ #2 lineup I am hoping for. For now, all I can do is wait and beg...
Please Gardy PLEASE bat Mauer second!


